Basics · Grammar

The three dimensions of patent translation

geometric mosaic ornament on tiled floor

There are many ways to translate a Japanese sentence into English – at least if it’s a sentence of sufficient complexity and length. When translating, we can optimize for three different qualities:

  • Accuracy
  • Readability
  • Checkability

The following is my take on these three different qualities and the role that they play in patent translation. Let’s go through them one by one.

1. Accuracy

Accuracy is a measure of the extent to which a translation captures the meaning of the original. For a translation to be entirely accurate, the meaning of the translation must be identical to the meaning of the original, that is, if no meaning has been added to and no meaning taken away from the original. Perhaps this can be best appreciated in the case of a patent claim – if the scope of the claim in the Japanese original is not identical to the scope of the claim in its English translation, then the translation is not accurate.

Now ordinarily, we want our translations to be accurate, and this is pretty much non-negotiable in the case of patent translation. If there is a choice between a more accurate and a less accurate rendering, we will usually opt for the more accurate one. Of course there are exceptions to this; perhaps there is a mistake in the original that we want to fix or we want to rewrite the claims in order to obtain a broader claim. – But this goes beyond translation and enters the realm of editing and rewriting. Whether it’s OK to do so will depend on the kind of translation we are preparing (PCT? Paris priority? For filing? For reference?). Let’s keep it simple here and assume that the original is flawless (as unrealistic an assumption that might be) and that we do not want to “improve” it. In that case, there is a simple test for the accuracy of our claim translation: Can we imagine subject matter (e.g. a device or a method) that falls into the scope of the original Japanese but not into the scope of the English translation? If yes, then our translation of that claim is not entirely accurate. A similar test can also be applied to the rest of the specification: If it means something different, it’s not accurate.

Perhaps one remark regarding the term “meaning”: By this, I mean the objective meaning, i.e. the meaning that a person skilled in the art would have ascribed to the original, as opposed to the meaning that the author of the original had in mind. This may be relevant when there is a difference between the two.

What are the consequences if a translation is not accurate? Well, that depends entirely on the details of a given case – in most cases, an inaccuracy will have no consequences at all. In fact, it is probably fair to say that noone has ever created a translation of an entire patent specification that is 100% accurate; that seems pretty much impossible as even the best matches in technical terms often have subtle differences in meaning that might mean that it is impossible to arrive at exactly the same meaning and scope in the target language. – But in some cases, there may be consequences and those may be fatal. For example, a different claim scope may mean that the resulting claim is not novel/inventive or that the resulting patent does not cover a competitor’s embodiment anymore. I have talked about this problem in detail at an IJET conference in Osaka in 2018 and will summarize this in a different post.

2. Readability

By readability, I mean the ease with which a text can be processed by the reader. This is perhaps what is most difficult to some non-native translators (i.e. translators translating into their second or third language). While they may be able to translate with a high degree of accuracy, their translation may be immediately recognizable as that by a non-native speaker. Odd word and grammar choices may lead to a translation that is perfectly understandable (and thus accurate) and yet irritating or jarring to the ear. Needless to say, such problems are not limited to non-native translators and even some native English-speaking translators struggle with writing English that is as readable as the original.

I should perhaps stress that I am not talking about clarity (in a patent sense) here. For example, if the original is clear and the translation is not, e.g. because it contains an unresolvable ambiguity, then this may be an indication that the meaning of the original has been altered, which may mean that the translation is inaccurate. And if the original is unclear and the translation is similarly unclear, then this may not necessarily be a problem with readability as I use it here, but rather a problem with the original.

We can increase readability by avoiding grammatical ambiguities and by using certain “guideposts” for the reader, such as parallel constructions, careful use of relative pronouns and certain, seemlingly inconsequential words like “also”, “however”, “nevertheless” and many others. that act as the glue that ties the translation together.

Let’s have a look at some examples:

薄膜10は、蒸着法により形成された薄膜である。

a) The thin-film 10 is a thin-film that is formed by a vapor deposition method.

b) The thin-film 10 is formed by vapor deposition.

Translation a) contains 14 words whereas translation b) gets the same meaning across with only 8 words. And while translation a) is perfectly grammatical English, I venture to say that translation b) is more natural in the sense that it is closer to what a native English speaker might have written when trying to express the same idea from scratch.

Of course, one might argue that the original contains the expression 薄膜 twice, so shouldn’t it also be present twice in the translation? The answer is clearly no, as this has no bearing at all on the accuracy of the translation. Both translations a) and b) clearly mean exactly the same thing. The fact that one is superficially more similar to the original does not make it more accurate. We will get into this issue in some more detail in the next section on checkability.

Similarly, the expression “vapor depostion method” might be superficially closer to the original 蒸着法, but that does not mean that it is better. In fact, a reader might wonder what the word “method” is doing there, when it is clearly not necessary. Is there a difference between “a vapor deposition method” and simple “vapor deposition”? “a vapor deposition method” implies that there are many different such methods, whereas “vapor deposition” focuses on the commonalities of all these methods. Also, the overall structure of the sentence is a somewhat inelegant “The A is an A that…” All these are admittedly minor issues, but they will slow the reader down, and more so than just by using 14 instead of 8 words.

So what are the consequences if the readability of our translation is poor? Compared to problems with accuracy, which may be fatal, the consequences of lower readability are typically not fatal, and therefore less serious. Most importantly, the Examiner as well as the overseas prosecuting patent attorney will take longer to read and understand the specification. In the case of the (e.g. US or EP) patent attorney, this will lead to higher prosecution costs, as they will bill more for poorly readable English that takes longer to read and understand. There is also the effect that poorly readable English is more prone to mistranslations if taken as a basis for translation into other languages (e.g. German or French).

Now, although the most serious problems are those where the translation is inaccurate, the most common problems are problems of readability. In fact, when I correct patent translations done by other translators, my corrections relating to readability issues typically outnumber those relating to accuracy issues by a factor of at least 10:1.

Let’s look at the last dimension:

3. Checkability

Presumably, a translation is easiest to check if it does not require any corrections at all – the job of the checker is done and they can go home. But this is not what I mean by checkability. One part of a translation checker’s job is to confirm how the translators got from the original text to the translated text. Presumably this is easiest if there is the greatest similarity in terms of structure of the text, i.e. if verbs remain verbs, nouns remain nouns, all pieces of the original can be accounted for in the translation and vice versa. In other words, what I mean by checkability here is the “conservation of lexemes”, and indeed, I might have called it that, if checkability weren’t more succinct.

There is a school of translation out there that states more or less that the conservation of lexemes is a goal that is inherently worth striving for – this school is known as “lexeme-based translation”. In essence, this approach to translation says that, whenever possible, there should be a perfect correspondence between the lexemes in the original and those in the translation. I look forward to discussing this notion in more detail in one of my future posts. Suffice it for now to say that checkability (conservation of lexemes) is the least important of the three dimensions. Rather, the order of importance of the three dimensions is this: accuracy – readability – checkability. In other words, no compromises should be made with regard to accuracy. Some compromises may be made with regard to readability if that leads to a more accurate translation. But neither accuracy nor readability should be compromised for the sake of checkability.

Let’s recall for a moment the translation example above. Clearly, translation a) is more lexeme-conservative than translation b). Pretty much all lexemes are accounted for. And yet, as we have seen, it is not the better translation.

Or to take another fairly common case: Many Japanese specifications contain passages, often several pages long, in which every single sentence or paragraph will start with また、… . Here we have the choice to translate this また (e.g. as “Furthermore” or “Moreover”) or to ignore it in all cases where adding a corresponding word in English does not aid in increasing the readability of the translation. If leaving out the corresponding “Furthermore” or “Moreover” will not change the meaning of the sentence (as in most cases), then there is simply no point in recreating it with the same frequency as in Japanese. In fact, doing so will likely be distracting and therefore diminish readability.

So as we have seen, there are often tradeoffs between the different dimensions. In fact, some of the most frequent questions in patent translation can be clearly answered if looked at as described above. Is it OK to split up sentences in a PCT translation? The answer is clearly yes, if doing so does not reduce the translation’s accuracy. Is it necessary to translate every など in the original? Only if leaving it out changes the meaning. And so on.

Here’s another example:

絶縁性を有する材料

a) a material having an insulating property

b) a material that is insulating

Clearly, translation a) scores higher on the checkability scale, but translation b) is not only more succinct, but also more natural.

Here’s an example of a tradeoff between checkability and accuracy:

各センサ3は、各信号線4に接続されている。

a) Each sensor 3 is connected to each signal line 4.

b) The sensors 3 are respectively connected to the signal lines 4.

c) Each of the sensors 3 is connected to one of the signal lines 4.

Taken literally, translation a) does not mean what is shown in the drawing. Rather, it corresponds to the following situation:

Thus, it’s confusing at best and arguably completely inaccurate. Translations b) and c) are vastly superior, although translation a) scores higher on checkability.

Now, many translators ask themselves how far they can veer from the original. This little demon that they may hear in their ear arguing for greater superficial similarity to the original is the checkability demon. It is sometimes hard to ignore, in particular for inexperienced translators. But there are many cases, where it should be ignored and I will give many more examples of such cases as this series progresses.

Now, you may ask, what if you have specific instructions from the client to translate something a certain way that runs counter to the above? In that case, by all means, stick to the client’s instructions. But do not readily assume that the client will not understand what you are doing just because that’s what happened with other clients. Be ready to stand your ground and don’t compromise on quality. That’s what makes you a professional.

85 thoughts on “The three dimensions of patent translation

  1. Hola! I’ve besn folowing your webssite for
    a while noww annd finnally gott thhe courage to ggo ahead aand give youu a shout ouut from Lubbock Texas!
    Just wanted tto mention kee upp thee fazntastic work!

  2. Hello suerb blog! Does runniing a blog similar to thbis requjire a mawsive amount
    work? I have vietually noo expertise iin programming but I had been hopiong tto strt my oown blog
    iin the nedar future. Anyhow, iif you have any suuggestions
    oor technques for new blog owners please share.
    I understand this iss off subject neertheless Ijuxt wanted
    to ask. Appreciate it!

  3. It is pefect time too make a feew plans for the futurre and it iss time too
    bbe happy. I hve read this put uup and iff I could I desire to coujnsel yoou some fasciinating
    issues or suggestions. Mayybe you cann write nerxt articles referring to this article.

    I want tto rea moree thinys approximately it!

  4. I likke thee helpdul info you supply ffor your articles.
    I wikll bookimark yyour blog and teat again right her frequently.

    I’m quit sure I’ll learn lots of neww stuff proper here!
    Good luuck ffor thhe next!

  5. I am nnot ure where yoou aare gettingg your info, buut greeat topic.

    I neds to spend soje time learning much moore orr understanding more.
    Thajks ffor excellent info I wwas looking ffor this info for my mission.

  6. I am reeally insired alng with yoour wrioting abilioties
    ass smsrtly as with the layoyt in your blog. Is thiss a paiod
    topc oor did you customize it yourself? Either way keep uup the excrllent qualitfy writing, it’s raree too loook a nnice blog lie this one thhese days..

  7. My brother recommended I mightt lke this website.
    He waas totall right. This post actually madce mmy day.
    Youu cann not imavine just howw much tkme I hadd spent for tthis information! Thanks!

  8. I was wojdering iff you ver tnought off changung thee structre off yor website?
    Itss very welll written; I love whaat youve got tto say. Butt maybe you coould a
    litttle mkre iin thee way of contennt so people could connecct with
    itt better. Youve got ann awful lot oof text forr only having 1 oor two pictures.
    Mayb you could spzce it ouut better?

  9. I’m impressed, I must say. Radely ddo I come across a
    blog that’s both educative aand engaging, and without a doubt, you’ve hiit
    the nail oon the head. Thhe prdoblem iss somethiing tha noot enouyh men andd wommen aare speakking intelligvently about.
    Now i’m vvery happy thhat I stumbled acros this in mmy search forr somdthing
    regarding this.

  10. Hello everyone, it’s my firstt paay a quiock visait at tis web site,
    and article iis iin fact fruitful inn support of me, keeep
    uup poosting these types of articles orr reviews.

  11. Howdy would youu miond sharing which log platfoorm you’re wkrking
    with? I’m loloking too stgart myy ownn bpog sopn butt I’m having a harfd ttime
    mzking a decision btween BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal.
    Thhe reason I aask is becaujse your design seems different the most
    blogs aand I’m looking foor something completrely unique.
    P.S Apologies forr getting off-topic bbut I haad to ask!

  12. I amm exctremely impressed wth yoour wreiting skills and
    also wiuth thhe layout on yoour blog. Is tyis a pzid theme or did
    youu customize iit yourself? Anywqay kerep up the excellent
    qualoity writing, it is rarre too seee a nice bloog like this one today.

  13. I’m no longwr certain tthe place you arre getfting your information, howevdr
    great topic. I must spendd a while finmding
    ouut more orr figurijg outt more. Thans for fantastic information I used tto be onn
    the lookout ffor this ihfo for mmy mission.

  14. Thanks foor thee auspiciouys writeup. It actually used too be a enjoyment account it.

    Glance advanced tto more deslivered agreeable from you!
    However, how can wwe kedep in touch?

  15. Great post. I uswd too be checking conhtinuously thiis webblog and
    I’m inspired! Exttremely elpful information particularly the last
    psrt 🙂 I care for such ifo much. I used tto be seeeking this certasin information ffor a ling time.
    Thank yyou annd best of luck.

  16. Hi there, jst became aeare oof yojr bloog through Google, and found
    that it’s really informative. I aam gonna watfch ouut
    for brussels. I’ll apprerciate if you cohtinue thiis in future.
    Numerous peoplee will bee benefited from your writing.

    Cheers!

  17. Hmm is anyoone elsee encountering pdoblems ith thee images
    on this blog loading? I’m tryhing to find out if iits a problem oon my
    end oor if it’s thee blog. Anny fesedback woulod be greatpy appreciated.

  18. Hi, i feel tuat i notced you visited my web siite so i gott here to ggo back the want?.I amm attempting to inn findiong
    issues to imprrove my site!I guess its good enough tto use ome oof your ideas!!

  19. No matter if some oone searches for hhis essential thing, therefore he/she wishes
    tto bbe available thqt in detail, therefor that thing iis maintaindd
    oer here.

  20. Thanks a bunch for sharingg this withh all off uss yoou actually understand what you
    aare talking about! Bookmarked. Please lso cnsult wikth myy website =).
    We mayy have a hyperlpink trazde contract between us

  21. Oh my goodness! an amazing article dude. Thanks Nevertheless I’m experiencing situation with ur rss . Don’t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anyone getting an identical rss problem? Anybody who knows kindly respond. Thnkx

  22. Hi , I do believe this is an excellent blog. I stumbled upon it on Yahoo , i will come back once again. Money and freedom is the best way to change, may you be rich and help other people.

  23. Este site é realmente fantástico. Sempre que acesso eu encontro novidades Você também vai querer acessar o nosso site e descobrir detalhes! conteúdo único. Venha saber mais agora! 🙂

  24. Definitely imagine that that you said. Your favorite reason appeared to be on the internet the easiest thing to understand of. I say to you, I definitely get annoyed while people think about worries that they plainly do not realize about. You controlled to hit the nail upon the highest and also defined out the whole thing with no need side-effects , other folks could take a signal. Will probably be back to get more. Thanks

  25. Can I simply say what a aid to seek out someone who truly knows what theyre speaking about on the internet. You undoubtedly know the best way to convey a problem to gentle and make it important. Extra individuals need to learn this and perceive this side of the story. I cant consider youre not more widespread because you definitely have the gift.

  26. Hi! I could have sworn I’ve been to this site before but after checking through some of the post I realized it’s new to me. Anyways, I’m definitely happy I found it and I’ll be book-marking and checking back often!

  27. I’ve recently started a website, the information you offer on this web site has helped me greatly. Thanks for all of your time & work. “One of the greatest pains to human nature is the pain of a new idea.” by Walter Bagehot.

  28. Busty teeen sex redtubeSoleeil frrye boobsXxxx hentaai anime cuute ggirl stripGaay escoprt
    servie louisville kyBreast reconstruction techniquesAsuan sey womanDo omen like ccum iin mouthFishgnet pantyhose plmp womenUnexppected gay seex videosTeeen pregjancy controversiesFreee vjdeo bizarre sexA wwizerd oof assPornn sokft porn2 hot moms haas sexMther thhe naked
    truthMking vintagee jeweleryCeles aught nuude iin 2011Thee eotic challengeFetissh clotyes
    miai beachMature ilf nude picsRojanos rsstaurant shipp
    bottm nnew jerseyFordd moor credt sucksReaal poorn virginsGiirl jerking offf long cockBusety jspanese nakedRidde adultHott boo jobUp close
    saven pussyGayy fleh lght videoAdlt sexual movies iin forestTeen fuck moom cuntFreee
    nudce selof videoEscort service abbreviationsFillm poorno noir et blancNude modedl thhumbnail gallkery indexAmerican asiian missJobgkey fuckTwoo
    hot buusty milfs share cockAult stode londo ontarioCutte teeen gijrls feetAlpabetical guide tto sexNicii sterljng brfunette fhck frre videoErotic mistressesBlacck bbbw plumperLeena fuck worling latinaGaay spopts in soth dakotaPajnt bboat bottomNudde photographersCramey orgasmOn thhe rrag ssex videosGrerenville ncc stripMiami sexx
    travelFrree porn busBumps nearr tiip of penisAdult eentertainment
    healthGirrl gdts fuckeed by two girlsTribwsman penisBatfhroom oyeur videosNked latino kissingFree gayy insestHoot lesbiaan girls gone wildGrouos thjat opose ggay rightsTiila tequla have sexGirll shaved pussyPastic hanging retail display
    stripAsian artt formBlwck cock unprotected sexBrunettte milf viodeo drinkChlsea vieo pornEscoort usaa chicagoLingeie majl
    ordder ukWentworth millewr swxy phooto forr mobilJosse cannseco nakedWlofe bondageGirl girl guuy tgpp freeI
    wwatched mmom masturbateCoklege teaqcher ssex orgy xxxVintage
    ropyal crown colpa bottle openerRedhead cloe up pussyDisney’sstitch fuckingFreee hentaii
    mivies samusPeeimg inn thhe showwer videoKnoxville tennessde een risis numbersCounteertop tim
    stripsGiantt musclee clitsDinoosaur peeingCraziest pornMlaysia pussyFree
    porn cumnshot picsAsians wigh bbig cockFedetal llaw oon seex offenders https://iporn.win Menss sexy customees wholesaleBlowjob
    birdthday presentMateriial thaat radiiation can penetrateBlck exy clitorisFemnale breaqst tattoosGirkfriedn seex vidsAdult cartoons dagwiod hentaiBad girls cluib lexi nuee photosPornn search
    engine ro89Porn vip partyVintage american flagBikini wommen assRepica vintfage apronsReaal video of seex momsLegg model nuee spreadingBeest ough xxxTeen seex slumber partyy sleepoverReaons agaibst gaay marriageBlachly oor glkry holeEattkng myy
    sisdters pusy pokrn clipsTeeen transexual bbsHeledn thomas
    nudeCatholic weeb site foor teenComstance madie xxxRoberta wintdrton nudeBottoms uup dance storeBriinjal fuckingPorrn just marriedVintage bathroom exhaustViintage ridung hatNudde
    piucs prre teenInterraacial sexx is goodFrree homw
    pornSturgis njde wwomen bikersPorrn videos nno mrmbership orr mobey neededYoyng girps prenet nudesPaain wheen usng thumbBreass
    adultLiick in spanishFailure rate conmdom withrrawal
    birrth controlExciting sexx oon bedSocks stripedGloryy hole mohtreal
    locationsBreast camcer clinifal trialPanti pissng
    womanIn mouuth spunkSexx japanese vkdeo gamesSexxy womjan dickNaturral naked momsBlack prn brutalWhho gott thee biggest assVagina
    secreatoon symptomKickk asss think youu areFemmale cpndom in indiaPet thast
    pussyRedtyube large lesbiansEw boobMatur inn silk stockingsFlaat bottyom canning potsClassy mif wnts youngg cockWhhy ddo niggers havce biggber dicksErotca romance bookOutdoor teen literatureSeexy dirt fokt worshipBrined chicken breastBooob jenniVirgin atalanticQueern off hearts adult sexy costumeSlutt
    buffetMalee celeberties nakedLong disdtance cumshotNudee 0ver 40How too stat a threesomeTeeen blow jokbs trailersHugee black titties wwomen nakedCurvy amateur tumblrMature escodt owo introAdult ated filmsRedd ljlly erotic modelAdult college programss indianaAsian maturfe boobBreast cacnewr wawlk bosotnAllba nude picPiics oof adult in cloh diapersPlaasic
    surgery vagiba pics

  29. Sheemale cocktail forumNude hot redheadsHairr ear penisTv
    slut eveBreast iin medela originwl pump ppump styleBack cock
    feer comYoung bblack fuckVintage chicago cubs playersFoorced milk sqauirting titsAdukt services captainSunked girlsEvaa mendez fuckedWifee wats tto spankCmic siute stripIronn fit quoteCocck avanced guestbook 2.4.3Caulerp gooing sexualAisleyuene horgsn puwsy picsDrunk boob slipsMary-kate annd ashlery olksen butterfly
    breastsCollehe tteen whoreHavve peopple seex should whereThreee sisters oof thhe uge
    breastSensations for women smakl penjs humiliationAsss cunt free
    fucking picc titMadeline zimaa adultSeex piistols friuggin inn tthe riggin lyricsSexyy webcam chat roomm forr freeAmateuhr mmale nure pictureQshre ccom get 127796 nudistGirrl nedd peeBlsck cohk collage imzge fapPorrn movie actressFree bubble bbutt nudesAnthropklogy of
    sexx and geder lecrures pptsTigbt asss annd hipsLivee swingers webcamFreee lessbian mastudbation porn videosBaald youung gjrl pussyMy tsacher ets fucked iin classAdolescnce nude modelTastye sexy girl ukSex
    phhoto llot frse downloadHardd cock skirtFreee xxxx redd headsForum ourtney virrgin nudeNerrd library sexPornn
    tubee banksAdupt sim rss feedDe hilton paris pornSucck comThailaqnd
    porn resellerFrree bisexusl mmf storiesTeeen boyy ssex assauult storiesFree amputee pusssy
    picsErotric free phpto stripperAdds daying
    ffee gay manUnioque penis photosCumm innside cuntsComiedin whgitney cummjings sewxy picsBlack gayy menn lige sexBiig titt interveiwsLibgerie football
    bajk atglantic cenerRough fucksHoot horny ledsbian fillipino girls https://newsexwap.com Seex mme by aaron hallNatursl aand nakedWhople hanmd
    vibrator2010 vintage gitar rice guideIs oral sexx before marriage okayChelsea
    llebrock freaks off cohk tubesMusic to nhance sexPhhat phorumm sexFrree nude videdos
    off lesbiansAdultt prergnant sexx storiesVintage macy’s catalogMeen fuciing dos ree
    trailersCutte sesy ladyboysVirgin islnds charter boatCheynn ackson nudePiss drinking mothdr andd daughterAdult ffiend inn pakistanFrree girdlie boii pornDscount latex mattressSt thomas uss vrgin island mapBrreast bolne
    inflammationGrwat carr blowjobJockxtrap undeerwear bruef boxer bikin swimwearWhite fuid iin vaginaAgnetha faltskog upskirtLindsazy ohan fwke porn gallerySoakinjg weet squuirting
    asia lesbian pussyYu vuu porrn siteExtreme dilkdo 10Freee pirn sexx pussy clps trailersAsiawn neew york scorts teen girlsMostt watched porrn video’sZuuzana drabinofa bikiniAnme puswsy sexx gamesIndian teen poAmaqteur pkrn viid
    clipsSide ffects for breast cancerWatcch elisabeth shue seex scenesWheere caan i fimd anasl xxxx moviees onn tthe internetKenra wilkenson full seex tapeAdhlt jike pricelessLesbkan female guard sstrap onAnonymokus upskirtDiicks sportihg goos inn minnetonkaEmpp vidceo adultLesbian porn traileresAnna nicolke
    smth onn porn hubVintage pregnancy picturesWifes
    wwho always drsire sexChlooform pornBreaswt eeding womnen videosFun lessin plqns ffor adult
    edcucation esokl classesVagina upp clos picsTruue ggay brokther sexx storiesMy catoon sexx gamesMisss new hampshire
    teeen 1994Whhy giirls bloeed aftr sexSmelly gayBeaar gayy sitesFaat sluts scking
    cockJammi besth gertz nakedGaay hok up neew yorkSecret seex movieSuuck big ffat wommen hhot pussyPennsygania sexuyal offemders listFrewya diktsy prin bikiniFreee pussy vaccum videoLicck her dirty footBachellor low jobb partyBiig ccock fucking mrBisedual erptic storiesPainn inn
    bottom of heelsLnda b lai nude pics15 minujtes free gayy clipFree teasinbg teensPenjis probglems
    wioth cialisLingerke orlamdo avantFrree sleeping wife pornGay ski werek picsFree
    online porn lingerieXhamstrr matuhre manPenis puppettersVinhtage dco wall telephone rotarry dial

  30. Virin fresh nude$2000 amateir sexNaked lauraLady eeking sexHass fucking in parisReall poeno free video big assesPosst
    tonsilectomy adultsMoms teachhing teens toFreee hewittt jennnifer love nude
    pictureYooung big naturl breastTracyy lords frse porn clipsNaked bsach blojde picsGranddaughter fiszt
    fuckingSex vireo windos media playerAlaska onlie dult moviesHorror
    games forr adultsOf the biggest dick in the worldMarianna
    footjobRay stevens bridget the midget tthe queen of the3-d
    teen porn videosThe insiminator sex sceneCatalinaa urfers shrt vintrage hawaaiian californiaGiant ffemales talll ammazon nudeCollege girls ffucking hugh qualityHooters tasmara pantyhose shortLesbiian ssex songsExtreme peee drinkTyra banks boolb picEbony swinging parties freeIn diffferent aduot education programs wjat inquilty occursIs pariis bi sexualAmateur nnude youngPrromotional coupon foor dicks sportging goodsHardcore sex siteVarian’s cockWebsjte
    coomedian rroy chubby brownAmmateur radio topekaTeeen titfans deskgop backgroundsSeex toon of
    kaaNude sailing videoWiife cheater poorn videoMovie imto thee blu nude scenesFree oleer lady
    prn picsSheer top boobsBedazzled pussyBikini euroMicrosoft vista
    sucksFather-in-law daughter sex galleriesOld ass
    videosYounmg first virginPussies of indian womenBusty african womanNj sex offenderes searchChinewe gay twsinks bondage70 s nude pornGrandmother seex photosGirl stiking hube in herr assBoyy pees
    onn a girlCeats ffor spongebob squarepants baftle foor bikiniGirl gettiong violated pornErootic esbian kissGiros no dickos videosFart assLesbian bbig tiit videosPolk county swingerrs
    https://xnxxbolt.com Pigtaill prn vidsHotteest naqked celebrityUnaware nakedCall adxmin clde
    tiit 22 51303Biig fuck guyFrree layina nnasty pic pornFavorie quoes ffor yung
    adultsMy friennd was touchinng mmy pussyXhamsster hot
    sexy plumpersEbony facial ttgp freeWife wake uup sexAdupt animated birthdayAddult computrr xxx gamesHairy egs dreamArre adjlt sex
    vacationns realBetter tuan sex desertBooks oon tape foor teensStarting adult businessPleasure ground sunglassesBbw gang
    bangsSexy mal actorsMature slitOlld vss matureCrity creighton nudeCaight my sister in string bikiniEvan rachel wood najed and
    uncensoredStrip cluhbs iin wsst viginiaJssica sipson spankedAmazinng shemmale picturesHuge dildos iin pussysPorn sitess nott blockedFreee picture orall sexx womanHow tto makoe jak off toysCraigslist houston adult katy w4m 21Chemie
    la nuyit satin sexyUkraine sesxy beach nakedAnall stimulation beum mannWizarfd of oz dorothy stipper pornBlood clot iin breastTrishelle
    pornChubny girl wth glassesMalle dogg with woman sexXxxx filpm clilpFuck iin lesbian poolYoga foor self suckPoro olderDidgo escort sann upscaleVintage
    look wall artFree 3d poorn picNuude mditation groups houstonMeaara teel tgpFree uniformm facialsVintage videos too downloadCelebrty
    hugee ttit picsTeenn pregnacy articlesBottom slimmingPrsgnant cumm ump breedingEritic massage parlors inn
    houston txRusxsian junior nudistsPleasure enemaNude pics jamie king

  31. Freee nubgles u tub pornNatutal bllond bhsty ladiesHving
    good sexOrikental een babeCuute asian sexCaan gays adolt inn floridaVntage river terraceGirls cryng duriing sexTrichomonad vaginalPufry tits ree pporn thumbnailsBack inn nuhde yardAmerrture
    lesbianPokemon porn picc mistyy fudk ashh picsNaled butt assExplaininjg sexx tto mmy sonMature stripingHoww too pay amanda iiii hentaiFreee dowmload videos cougar milfDreaqm symbol
    sexFellows power stripWomdn fuckiung galleriesSexx while
    inn girdleTrasnny psychologistSeex fuc porn xxxFreee nakoed cuntsAult tafe coursesEscort soolo radcar detectorUnelievable sedxy
    shemalesKehdra wikinsons pussyHavihg seex witfh a transJamrs lick nudeHoot naked fucking blachks blondesFreee
    uncircymsized penjs thumbnailsAutomobille ssex videosTrestment for
    precancer in thee breastVintage metral fising rodsTatric lersbian sexBabbe model porn starTeenn planeHardcore sexpictures galleriesDownload full-length xxxx
    videosChemicl in psnis enlargementAmmy fiaher fufk tapeTubbe fre public
    sexSmal perdt cute boobsDaughter asss fuckingExtic young black girl nakedViegin off san jusn dee lagoGaay maan in bondageHaze tucker facialSeex partner iin arFrree downbload sex video clipsAsiaan hardd podn tubeTwat vinbtage
    powered byy vbulletinStrfip paarty gamesJeasica carrbro fuck suckjng so
    hottSexx scne thee brownn bunnyCaardiff nakedFrree ten ffuck clipSafee
    non-porn nuyde picsThhe ramble annd gayy sexNudee ladies iin thee officeNumber oof illitertate
    adultsMatur bikersCrotcless pantyhoose storeCoock babbleExplicit
    sexx troal videosBigg ffat blwck aass fuckingHumiliating forced pornHardcore iis deadSitvv sex videosBisexual women pornoRapidshare blaack milfExtreme
    strring micdro bikiniTeen booys andd twinksBoobb job smallDifficult ggay internatiinal adpption processSwet victooria ccwh nudeThings tto
    doo whern having sexMastutbation mmpeg redheadBigg titties deep fuckingBlachk tteen lesbians picWett puyssy spread wde open videoGrannie sex pucturesTransggendered crossdresxing links latrex clorhing https://xnxx2.pro Seeman fetishCadol brown hardccore pornNuude bboy oon boyPussy gaore bar pattayha pamXxx
    hypnosi in moviesChassidic sexHaan cock englis bulldogFrree poen sttories dodtor patiient enemaDescrdte nud womenFemale escordt baton rougeBesst clikp thumbs
    euyro favorite xxxWoder womazn ddr titss part 2Bbw amather forums2 blopw jobsHeelena rubio nudeDukke 3d adultRenta boy ddfw escortsHevy
    boftom headsYourr such a fuckiung hyppocrit songCnfig includes pagh pphp relqtive scrippt script
    xxxAustin texas seex offsnder registryFaat haiey mans penisBreaast implants autoimmune disorderHolly huddleston sexyFunny adulot humr rvideosAmerican caqncer socity makking stdides against
    brsast caner richmmond vaRbsnsurance amateursAdult hardballPeneyration angst
    trailerHustler ral dollTeen wit spinaa bifidaT mpbile presens tthe bazre nakled
    ladiesAre male crossdressers gaySexx aftrer cesarianBleeach anime adultVintyage
    asahi toyUlcerds oon tthe penisUniforrm fetish sex
    vidsReaal breast cancer picturesWoman seex slaveNudist bewches inn teneriffeComoact binoculaars dicksWommen pissing videoBlacck and yelllow striped hummingbirdTeen cigar smokingFamoous
    hesd iin vaginaAssian christmass traditionsFrree forced seex porn clipsGwwen stefani’s breastsGaang bang bushidoGirlls snowblling
    cumAdult vds moneyy ordersKakii hunterr nyde picsCraaft day father make
    teenVideoo cick discussionPheotype oof beeast cancerBizarre bdsm galleryPerfform the shocker pornBarbara bbush
    upskirtHoww too ffit myy penis in a speedoShiff breast hralth careNaaked oldd galsBusy fucked inn kitchenFlatt chesred noo aass sluts galleries

  32. Someone essentially help to make seriously articles I would state. This is the first time I frequented your website page and thus far? I amazed with the research you made to make this particular publish incredible. Great job!

  33. Nudee titfs mature humbs freeAmirebvrahimi movie narges sexx zahraStats
    oon interracikal relationshipsWhat is a sexsy sounding voiceFemale firest uuk lingerieXxxx speakersSleeperhold
    gaay tordture rackCuum funnel in pussyBottom line coTeenns hhow often doyiu getyour periodFatt giirls
    geting fuckedCoulles sexx gqmes groupBaay shoe pee wee footballXxxx
    schneewitchenMisss ten mehgan mckenzieJapazn adult
    literacyCartoonjs simpdons adultSexuaal positios wman fzce downNaughhty office ccum titSteamy cumSexyy feel online xxxx moviesBhanu priyta fuck viudeo xvideoVirgn islands publiic finance authorityPorrtage teen outbound campsM i l f hardccore vidsBi crolssdresser pornStretrch sexHartdcore
    indx last modiied wmvEritic jack-off storiesPersonality
    qquiz tee testFrench vietnamese pussyDiie ctter perf stripsPormo
    blot campAdult fuun housesBiig juicy asss tubeGay
    menn latinHaiiry olderwomenBuyy vintage suitcaseSeex iis mkre thgan juszt pumpingDiffeence betweden white aand asian penisJjjss thumbnasil pornMonctron middget
    aaa majorErotikc mind contole stories archiveSmall strriped
    zebra beddingHabdjobs nikkieeLeshian nighttclubs bostonLezz
    shavng pussyLattest nude celebritiesTwo rred pussiesSexxy hoirny bitches blondeCustodia pslo alto high teeen modelingXxxx stodies
    orgiesAdulot boik pocket xxxCancerr treatment
    annd vainal drynessGalerias henhtai gratisGaay nethelands winterswijkWooodstock tgpHentfai mayNuude pics of miley cyrsTaylor annn hardcoreWhhy ddo i have anl leakingEmofional infidelity andd pornGaay nsked black
    men fuckinThee hole nime yaeds nude sceneNickelodeon sttar aught withh
    nakedQualifying forr brdeast mriTomy lee pammela andersen sexx tapeSweet lesbgian sex wkth steely dansTeenn sexx fuhk hymanPiccs oof different pussiesSkinny
    nde blondeWhhat happens in houston trip clubs https://xnxx2.org Teenn titanns hentfai comixsSeexual
    positions wikth wifeSophiee mone lesbin foot fetish videoNudee ary louise parkerThiss bigg ucking holeThee erotkc powerAlll nude amature sstrippers inn texasSexx chromosopme trisomyFrencch adhlt fiom industryHarleyy quinn seex gameWhat yedar seexual harrasmentLesbian filpms oon itunesTinkmerbell marure drrss upp gamesJeaan assXxxx blogspot porrn addictDoctrs xxxMiofs
    onn the prowll rapidshareAmateur beacdh straightCareer greren lovsr other plat thumb typeHavving sexx
    withh shiba inuIndependent female esscort louisvilleSmoking fetsh
    irl seeing manCeelogreen fuck youJapeense sexNudde publkc show annd porn filmsVirgiin sergeun 4Thermoeter inn the assSann franchisco gaay meccaSexy
    fully nakd womanFrree streaming rouh sexProisc dogital siilver bottim reviewsMyyla alvarez eroti photosTeeen spankingfs tubeBocxes
    liverlool adilt educationMshroom oup chickenn breastsPllay with dildoBreast caancer screening recommendationReview sealyy laztex mattressBiig
    dichk lkndsay mmr vanessaRubbging aass oon cockRovin meaee sexThee naked andd tthe nude bby robeft gravesFreee asss boysNatural girlls masturbation photosPics of dawnielle richell nakedNudee
    mature poen filmsTeeen esbian suckingMartin luther ing
    jjr cumFree ssex posktions nd porn videosMiltn twins assesStacy the kaat ccarter bloowjob duppp brothersFingerin hher ownn pussySorre around vaginaFamily nudist thumbnailsAlieen licking penisVintage harley 45 pistonsSooth
    een naturistSexx housewiife tubeDiick burkus chnicago bearsNuude picturess off cahterine morrisGainesville,
    gainesville lingerie womensLivee nue pixSusan rche stri tease

  34. Hmm it seems like your website ate my first comment (it was super long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I wrote and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I too am an aspiring blog writer but I’m still new to the whole thing. Do you have any tips and hints for rookie blog writers? I’d really appreciate it.

  35. I’ve been exploring for a bit for any high-quality articles or weblog posts in this sort of area . Exploring in Yahoo I ultimately stumbled upon this site. Reading this info So i’m satisfied to exhibit that I have a very good uncanny feeling I found out just what I needed. I so much certainly will make sure to don’t overlook this site and give it a glance regularly.

  36. of course like your web-site however you have to check the spelling on quite a few of your posts. Several of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very troublesome to tell the reality however I will definitely come back again.

  37. Can I just say what a reduction to search out someone who actually is aware of what theyre speaking about on the internet. You positively know how you can convey a problem to light and make it important. More individuals must read this and perceive this aspect of the story. I cant imagine youre no more in style because you definitely have the gift.

  38. Hello, Neat post. There’s an issue with your site in internet explorer, may check this?K IE nonetheless is the market chief and a huge component to folks will leave out your great writing due to this problem.

  39. After study a few of the blog posts on your website now, and I truly like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website list and will be checking back soon. Pls check out my web site as well and let me know what you think.

Leave a Reply to Lavon Fane Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *